VerifiAssist Blog

Aging dental A/R: how to follow up on unpaid insurance claims before they become write-offs

A simple weekly routine for following up on unpaid dental and ortho insurance claims, so aging A/R gets worked before it turns into write-offs.

Most unpaid insurance claims aren't denied. They're just sitting there. Nobody called, nobody checked the clearinghouse, and the claim quietly ages past 60 and then 90 days. By the time someone looks, the fix is harder, and sometimes the filing window has closed.

Here's a simple follow-up routine any dental or orthodontic office can run every week.

Why claims stall

Claims usually get stuck for ordinary reasons:

  • The claim was rejected at the clearinghouse and never reached the carrier.
  • The carrier needs something more, like X-rays, a narrative or periodontal charting.
  • Coordination of benefits is out of date, so the carrier is waiting on the patient.
  • The patient's eligibility was wrong on the date of service.
  • The claim was paid or denied, and nobody posted the EOB.
  • For ortho, an installment claim was never set up or quietly stopped going out.

None of these fix themselves. Every one of them gets harder with time.

Run an aging report every week

Pull the insurance aging report from your practice software once a week, on the same day. Sort it by age and by dollar amount. Then work it in this order:

  1. Anything close to a timely filing limit. Every carrier sets deadlines for submitting claims and for appeals. Know the limits for your main carriers, and treat anything getting close as urgent.
  2. The biggest balances. Major restorative and ortho cases come next.
  3. Claims over 30 days with no response. Silence at 30 days usually means something is wrong.

Check the clearinghouse first

Before you pick up the phone, check your clearinghouse reports. A claim that was rejected there never reached the carrier, so the carrier has no record of it. Fix the rejection and resubmit. This one step clears a lot of "lost" claims without a single call.

Then check the carrier

Use the carrier portal to see claim status. If it shows pending, find out exactly what it's waiting for. If it shows paid, find the payment and the EOB and post them. If the portal doesn't answer the question, call.

When you call, get a clear next step, not just a status. Ask what's missing, who needs to send it and when the claim will be reprocessed. Write down the rep's name, the date and the call reference number in the patient's account.

Work denials fast

A denial isn't the end. Read the reason code. Many denials come from fixable issues: a missing attachment, a frequency limit, a coding mismatch or an eligibility problem. Correct and resubmit, or appeal with the right documentation.

Track your denial reasons, too. If the same reason keeps coming back, the real fix is upstream, at verification or at claim entry.

Bring the patient in when you need them

Some claims stall because the carrier is waiting on the patient, often for an updated coordination of benefits form or an accident questionnaire. Call or text the patient and tell them exactly what to do. A two-minute call can release a claim that's been stuck for weeks.

Set a follow-up rhythm and stick to it

A simple schedule keeps claims from slipping through:

  • At 15 to 21 days: confirm the carrier received the claim.
  • At 30 days: check status and get a clear next step on anything pending.
  • Every two weeks after that: follow up until it's paid or resolved.
  • Before any write-off: make sure every option is used up, appeals included.

Fix the front end, too

A lot of aging A/R starts before the claim is ever filed. Wrong eligibility, a missed frequency limit or an old coordination of benefits form all show up later as stalled claims. Clean verification before the appointment is the cheapest A/R work there is. Our dental insurance verification checklist covers what to confirm.

When there isn't time to do it

The routine above works. The hard part is doing it every single week while the phones ring and patients check in. That's usually where A/R falls behind.

VerifiAssist gives dental and orthodontic practices a dedicated remote agent who works your insurance aging inside your own practice software and clearinghouse. Your agent follows up on claims, works denials and reports back on what was collected, so your team can stay focused on patients. See how our A/R follow-up works, or request a free Insurance Revenue Risk Audit and we'll show you where your claims are getting stuck.

Want to see where your insurance gaps are?

Get a free audit of your verification and claims process.